Chapter 7

State v. Scopes — The Monkey Trial

1925  ·  Dayton, Tennessee

Charge
Violation of the Butler Act (teaching evolution)
Verdict
Guilty — $100 fine; later reversed on a technicality

Overview

On the side of science, legendary trial lawyer Clarence Darrow defended biology teacher John Scopes against the famous orator William Jennings Bryan, who prosecuted Scopes' violation of Tennessee's anti-evolution statute. After an almost comical trial, Darrow asked the jury for a surprising verdict of guilty of his own client so Scopes could appeal. Bryan may have technically won the case, but in reality he lost when the Tennessee Supreme Court reversed the verdict.

Background

The American Civil Liberties Union offered to defend any teacher willing to challenge Tennessee's Butler Act, which prohibited the teaching of evolution in public schools. John Scopes, a young biology teacher in Dayton, agreed to be the test case. The trial became a national spectacle, broadcast on radio to millions. Darrow's masterstroke was calling Bryan — the prosecution's star witness — to the stand outside the courthouse and subjecting him to a withering cross-examination on the literal truth of the Bible.

Key Figures

Clarence Darrow
Defense attorney; legendary trial lawyer; deliberately sought a guilty verdict to enable appeal
William Jennings Bryan
Prosecutor; three-time presidential candidate; died five days after the trial
John Scopes
Biology teacher and defendant; agreed to be the ACLU's test case
H.L. Mencken
Journalist whose coverage shaped national perception of the trial

Legal Significance

Did Darrow lose the battle to win the war? Did Bryan not see the forest for the trees? The Scopes trial illustrates how lawyers engineer test cases for a particular result — a tactic still used today. It also demonstrates that a legal victory can be a cultural defeat, and vice versa.

How Would You Decide?

Did Darrow lose the battle to win the war? Can you spot a test case that lawyers engineer for a particular result?

Read the full case analysis in How Would You Decide? 10 Famous Trials that Changed History by J. Craig Williams.

Listen to the Podcast

The book has been adapted into a chapter-by-chapter podcast series on the Legal Talk Network, narrated by the author with approximately 100 voice actors playing the judges, lawyers, and witnesses.

Listen on Legal Talk NetworkListen on Apple PodcastsListen on SpotifyListen on Amazon Music