Chapter 4

Dred Scott, John Brown & Plessy v. Ferguson

1856–1896  ·  United States Supreme Court; Charles Town, Virginia

Charge
Treason, inciting rebellion, and murder (Brown); citizenship rights (Scott)
Verdict
Scott denied citizenship; Brown hanged; Plessy upheld 'separate but equal'

Overview

In 1856, a slave sued to gain his freedom, but in what has been called one of the worst historical decisions of the United States Supreme Court, the Court itself ruled Scott was not a citizen, and denied him access to the court system. John Brown's actions came on the heels of this decision, taking matters into his own hands. Not until 1896 did our Supreme Court address the injustice done to Dred Scott in the famous Plessy v. Ferguson case.

Background

Dred Scott had lived in free territories for years and sued for his freedom, only to be told by the Supreme Court that Black Americans had no standing to sue. This decision galvanized abolitionists, including John Brown, who raided the federal arsenal at Harpers Ferry in 1859 to spark a slave rebellion. Watching Brown's execution was a young Virginia Military Institute cadet named John Wilkes Booth. Plessy v. Ferguson in 1896 then enshrined 'separate but equal' as constitutional doctrine.

Key Figures

Dred Scott
Enslaved man who sued for his freedom; denied by the Supreme Court
Chief Justice Roger Taney
Authored the Dred Scott decision, ruling Black Americans were not citizens
John Brown
Abolitionist who raided Harpers Ferry; hanged for treason
John Wilkes Booth
Witnessed Brown's execution as a young cadet; later assassinated Lincoln

Legal Significance

Brown's closing remarks have been called 'one of the most memorable courtroom speeches' and 'one of the two greatest American speeches.' After Brown spoke, only one spectator clapped when the judge sentenced him to death. These three cases trace the arc of racial injustice in American law from the antebellum era through Reconstruction.

How Would You Decide?

How do Supreme Court decisions shape historical events? Are there lessons to draw from these cases today?

Read the full case analysis in How Would You Decide? 10 Famous Trials that Changed History by J. Craig Williams.

Listen to the Podcast

The book has been adapted into a chapter-by-chapter podcast series on the Legal Talk Network, narrated by the author with approximately 100 voice actors playing the judges, lawyers, and witnesses.

Listen on Legal Talk NetworkListen on Apple PodcastsListen on SpotifyListen on Amazon Music