Chapter 2

The Salem Witch Trials

1692  ·  Salem, Massachusetts Bay Colony

Charge
Witchcraft
Verdict
19 hanged, 1 pressed to death, over 200 accused

Overview

You can't really call them trials with this kind of procedure, but has criminal law advanced much further? Consider that the Miranda warning case has been overruled by the courts in just about every aspect except by name. See how the evidence admitted in 1692 varies from today's criminal proceedings, notably excepting the name of the charge: witchcraft.

Background

In the winter of 1692, a group of young girls in Salem Village, Massachusetts began exhibiting strange behavior and accused local women of bewitching them. The accusations spread rapidly, fueled by community tensions, religious fervor, and personal grudges. The Court of Oyer and Terminer was established to try the accused, and spectral evidence — testimony that the accused appeared to the witness in a dream or vision — was admitted as proof of guilt.

Key Figures

Cotton Mather
Puritan minister who supported the prosecutions and documented the trials
Judge Samuel Sewall
One of the presiding judges; later publicly apologized for his role
Tituba
Enslaved woman whose confession ignited the hysteria
Giles Corey
Accused wizard who was pressed to death for refusing to enter a plea

Legal Significance

The Salem trials stand as a cautionary tale about the dangers of mass hysteria, the admission of unreliable evidence, and the absence of due process. The procedures used — including spectral evidence, coerced confessions, and a presumption of guilt — would be inadmissible in any modern court.

How Would You Decide?

Did they admit the right kind of evidence needed to convict the witches? Has criminal law really advanced that much further?

Read the full case analysis in How Would You Decide? 10 Famous Trials that Changed History by J. Craig Williams.

Listen to the Podcast

The book has been adapted into a chapter-by-chapter podcast series on the Legal Talk Network, narrated by the author with approximately 100 voice actors playing the judges, lawyers, and witnesses.

Listen on Legal Talk NetworkListen on Apple PodcastsListen on SpotifyListen on Amazon Music