Chapter 9

The McMartin Preschool Trial

1987–1990  ·  Manhattan Beach, California

Charge
Child sexual abuse and satanic ritual abuse
Verdict
No convictions — longest and most expensive criminal trial in U.S. history at the time

Overview

The pendulum of child abuse concern had swung far to one side and in 1987, four teachers from the McMartin preschool faculty found themselves in the sights of Parent Judy Johnson. She was a woman later recognized as a paranoid schizophrenic, but who initially appeared as a concerned mother claiming child abuse of her two-and-a-half-year-old son at the preschool, later asserting highly inflamed allegations that the teachers performed satanic rituals with the kids.

Background

In 1983, Judy Johnson contacted police claiming her son had been abused at the McMartin Preschool in Manhattan Beach, California. Police sent a letter to 200 families asking if their children had been abused, triggering a wave of accusations. Children were interviewed using suggestive techniques by therapists at Children's Institute International. Seven defendants were originally charged; charges against five were dropped before trial. After six years and $15 million, the jury acquitted on 52 counts and deadlocked on 13 others.

Key Figures

Peggy McMartin Buckey
Preschool director; acquitted after years of prosecution
Ray Buckey
Teacher; faced two trials; never convicted
Judy Johnson
Parent whose accusations started the case; later diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia
Kee MacFarlane
Social worker whose suggestive interview techniques were later discredited

Legal Significance

How did the so-called expert psychologists and doctors present questionable findings based on unsubstantiated interviews? Did the media fan the fire with headlines without questioning the prosecutors? Did anyone win? The McMartin case became the defining example of the 'Satanic Panic' of the 1980s and led to major reforms in how child witness testimony is gathered.

How Would You Decide?

Did anyone win? How did suggestive interview techniques corrupt the evidence?

Read the full case analysis in How Would You Decide? 10 Famous Trials that Changed History by J. Craig Williams.

Listen to the Podcast

The book has been adapted into a chapter-by-chapter podcast series on the Legal Talk Network, narrated by the author with approximately 100 voice actors playing the judges, lawyers, and witnesses.

Listen on Legal Talk NetworkListen on Apple PodcastsListen on SpotifyListen on Amazon Music