Chapter 6

The Black Sox Trial

1921  ·  Chicago, Illinois

Charge
Conspiracy to defraud
Verdict
Not guilty — all eight players acquitted by jury

Overview

Nine players of the Chicago White Sox threw the 1919 World Series and caused a cheating scandal that forever changed the game of baseball. Even though these Boys of Summer didn't take the stand in their defense, they were found not guilty by a jury. Not to be dissuaded, the Commissioner of baseball got his revenge and struck the names of the 'Eight Men Out' from baseball's roster of players forever.

Background

The 1919 World Series fix was organized by gamblers who paid eight White Sox players to intentionally lose to the Cincinnati Reds. The scandal broke in 1920, and the players were indicted for conspiracy to defraud the public. At trial, the prosecution's case was severely damaged when the players' signed confessions mysteriously disappeared from the courthouse — allegedly stolen. The jury acquitted all eight, but newly appointed Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis banned them from baseball for life.

Key Figures

Shoeless Joe Jackson
Star outfielder; acquitted but banned for life; his guilt remains debated
Charles 'The Old Roman' Comiskey
Club owner whose notorious cheapness drove players toward the fix
Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis
Banned all eight players despite their acquittal
Arnold Rothstein
Alleged mastermind gambler behind the fix

Legal Significance

The Black Sox trial raises enduring questions about the relationship between legal acquittal and moral guilt. How did the prosecution's objections defeat the ballplayers' attempts to introduce evidence? Were their confessions extracted fairly? Was Shoeless Joe Jackson really in on the fix?

How Would You Decide?

Say it ain't so — but was Shoeless Joe really guilty? Does an acquittal mean innocence?

Read the full case analysis in How Would You Decide? 10 Famous Trials that Changed History by J. Craig Williams.

Listen to the Podcast

The book has been adapted into a chapter-by-chapter podcast series on the Legal Talk Network, narrated by the author with approximately 100 voice actors playing the judges, lawyers, and witnesses.

Listen on Legal Talk NetworkListen on Apple PodcastsListen on SpotifyListen on Amazon Music